Opting Out or Civil Disobedience

I am going to throw in my two cents on the issue of opting out.  Not because I believe in standardize tests or their questionable results.  I was torn because in the past, if a parent mentioned opting out, I though it could create an adversarial relationship between the parent and the school, often putting the student in the middle.  I swore I would never consider opt my daughter out because I didn’t want her teachers and schools to look bad or suffer any consequences.  I wasn’t ready to participate in a little civil disobedience.

But, I am no longer torn.  Before I can tell you why, I need to say a few things about testing.

High stakes testing is wrong.  Period.

No reliable research has ever shown that using test scores of students to evaluate teachers improves any aspect of public education.  If I am wrong and you can provide that research for me, please email me. I would love to read it.   Same with A/F grades, despite what our Superintendent tries to tell us, it is NOT working in Florida.

There is no reliable research that has shown that withholding a High School diploma from a Senior because he or she didn’t pass the right number of tests has done anything to improve that student’s motivation, self-worth, or future.   (We could argue all day about the idea that all student need to go straight to college or what we can do to ensure that those students who go to college are prepared… but that is a whole different issue…)

There is no meaningful or reliable research that shows anything beneficial about giving a standardized test in Language Arts to an 8-year-old and using the result to decide their placement for the next year.  Teachers who are on the front lines know this.  Reading specialists understand the danger.  Unfortunately, our State Superintendent doesn’t seem to understand the ramifications of the reform she has so stubbornly supported.  In fact, she has made the claim that it worked in Florida, but as Rob Miller so eloquently reminded us, those results are inflated and out of context.

Even worse is the plan to use that 8-year-old’s score on that Language Arts test without taking into account the countless data points (formal and informal) that highly qualified teachers have been collecting and observing for over three years.  And worse still is the plan to make that decision without allowing the parent to have the final say, or even an opinion, when they have most likely worked with teacher to whatever extent is possible, since their child was in kindergarten.

Sure, we have 6 Good Clause exceptions.  And there is a portfolio option (with little guidance about what they needs to look like or what students to keep it on or when they should start collecting artifacts…).  But let’s be honest, it’s still all about that test.  It’s about the test that every 5, 6, 7 and 8 year old in our state will soon be stressed over.  It’s about the test that will determine up to 50% of a school’s report card grade (if a school only goes up to third grade, like this one, the grade is based completely on the two 3rd Grade OCCT tests).

Back to opting out.  Like I mention earlier, until a few months ago, I would have been hesitant to opt out my daughter or to encourage other parents to pursue an way to opt their children out of tests.  I have worked at the state department and served on test committees and I understand that the data from the tests is important.  Like it or not, in order for the psychometrician to help make the test as valid as possible, they need kids to take the test.  If we have to have tests, I would have argued that we could at least have valid ones.  And, like it or not, that data is used to measure the effectiveness of our teachers and schools.

Then I heard about “A”.  “A” is a second grader in Moore.  “A” can read the early Harry Potter books.  He loves to read whatever he can get his hands on and is interested in.  He also happens to be good at math and science, as well as recently being the MVP in the inaugural season of the imaginary football league his friends and he created to play during recess.   Because when your teachers don’t let you play tackle or touch football at research, you just play the game with an imaginary ball.

No teacher would ever think to keep a portfolio of work on “A” or be thinking ahead to which good clause exception might save him.  And “A”’s mother, a teacher herself, had no reason to worry about him passing his third grade test…until this bright, energetic, creative, independent reader and second grader told his mom that he was worried about passing that reading test next year and not going to fourth grade.  Why does a second grader even know that this is a possibility.

This is why I am now in favor of parents having the option of opting their children out of tests.  Because no child should be that stressed over a test.  Ever.

No second grader should be stressed out about a test that is over a year away.   If “A” had not said something to his mom about being worried about it, he could have spent the next 18 months letting internalizing that worry, letting it simmer and grow, eating away at his confidence.   How many of our 5, 6, 7 and 8 year olds are internalizing the stress of their teachers and parents over a 50-question Language Arts test.  How many third graders will sit down to the test in April, the only thought in their head “If I don’t pass this test, I don’t get to go to fourth grade.”  How many students will be so worried about pleasing their teacher or their parent that they freeze up on test day?  And how well do you think those students are going to do… regardless of what reading level their DIBBELs and STAR tests say they are on?

How can we do that to our kids?  And for what reason?  I dare you to give me a good, research based reason.

The SDE is threatening reminding districts that if more than 10% of their students have no score, the school and district will automatically receive an F on their report card.   Let me put some context on that 10%.  If a grade has 60 students, it would take 7 kids “opting out” or not testing to earn that school an F.   For a larger school with 120 students, 13 missing scores would earn them an F.  In a smaller school, maybe with 13 or 14 students per grade level, it would take 2 students.  TWO.  No wonder schools have been adversarial when students try to opt out their students.

Our state superintendent doesn’t seem to like to talk with the liberal education establishment.  She doesn’t like to talk with OEA.  On twitter and Facebook, she is condescending and deflects real questions with vague responses.  She holds press conferences and invites the public, but then refuses to take questions from anyone accept the press.

If she doesn’t listen to the educational experts, maybe she will listen to parents, who are the experts on the most important part of this equation:  their kids.   I honestly believe that parents are the key to slowing down the educational reforms that are chocking our schools.

How crazy would it be if every school across the state had 11% of their students opt out, results in every district in the state getting an F.   I would love to see the spin on that story.  Maybe the grades would be released on time without being changed 27 times.  And as an added bonus, maybe the general public and our elected officials would fully understand how meaningless the A/F grades are.

I know that sounds like crazy talk, an extreme measure.  As a parent, I wonder if we are at the point that we need parents doing something extreme, something that is completely in the best interest of their children, in order to make our elected officials realize that High Stakes testing (RSA, TLE, A/F, ACE) is not what is needed or what is best for Oklahoma.

A little disclaimer: I am not going to organize a massive opt out across the state and all opinions expressed here are my own as a parent.   As a teacher with an degree in elementary education and certification in special education, I am fully aware of how important reading comprehension is for a student.  I am not against retention when it is a decision made in partnership with parent, teacher, counselor, and student.   I am not against data driven decision making (when the data is meaningful and taken in context).

I honestly hope that we don’t have to resort to the extreme of civil disobedience with a massive statewide opt out. But I will continue to help empower and inform other parents with the facts about education in Oklahoma and how they can advocate for their students.   It is my hope that our legislators are already listening to our concerns and asking the hard questions.


9 thoughts on “Opting Out or Civil Disobedience

  1. Donna says:

    I am a high school teacher and I have been doing a lot of research. Parents can and should opt out their kids on the “field testing”. That is the testing that our ss has volunteered our students to take for the testing companies that r only for the companies’ benefits. This will not affect the schools in any way. For the ” real” tests that count against the school there are two options only. One is to bombard the SDE with so many complaints and threats from parents that they finally stop the tests before they r ever administered. The other one is to take your child out of school and tell them u r going to home school them until the testing period is over then check them back in when it is over. It only affects the school when they r enrolled. It will affect the schools ADA ( average daily attendance) but if every school in the state did it then how could they punish any one school? This is my thought on the subject. I would like to hear anything better.

    • A student can also “opt out” by simply not answering the questions. It would result in a low score, which could in turn affect graduation (if they haven’t passed four EOIs). A school has to provide the opportunity to test, but cannot force it. They just have to document it.
      It is civil disobedience and I hate that parents and student might have to go to that extreme, but testing is getting out of hand.
      I am thankful my daughter is in preK and I have a few years.

    • Joy says:

      In my opinion, withdrawing to homeschool is not a good option for avoiding EOIs. First, some schools may balk at awarding credit for the course, which would affect graduation. Second, if the student does receive credit for the course, schools are required to offer that test in the next testing window. So, even if withdrawn during the spring window, the student will be enrolled to test at some point during the next school year. The winter, trimester, and spring windows are 60ish school days. You might as well homeschool outright if your district is one to utilize all of the testing windows.

      • Very true. The EOIs would be harder to “opt” out of compared to the 3rd grade test, although there is also a portfolio option for those as well (once they have failed the test twice). Once a student has passed four of the seven, for them personally, the other three tests mean nothing anyway and schools do not force the issue with retakes. Only the first test score counts toward accountability for the school.

  2. Donna Frick says:

    So, taking them out to homeschool for the testing period is acceptable? It can’t be held against him? How long of a period of time are we talking about? I have a third grade boy. This testing is out of control.

  3. As a 14 year veteran teacher and mom of four students from 9th-Pre-K, I am seriously considering opting out two of my children, whom are student’s similar to “A”. They will test very well and will definitely help their home school scores within our district, however am I willing to do that at their expense? I don’t like/agree with the aggressive nature of some of the information on this site, but it does give parents some useful guidelines and tools for opting out. http://www.unitedoptout.com
    The ONLY way it will stop is for the PARENTS to say NO! I am fearful of what this will do to my professional reputation, but if I can’t say NO when I am on the inside witnessing it everyday, I am part of the problem.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s